Why scintillating Paulo Bernardo should be given Celtic nod over Reo Hatate in Dortmund
Our man Craig Swan reckons the Portuguese midfield star can get the nod in Germany
Get the latest Celtic news sent straight to your inbox with our daily newsletter
Enter your Email…
Subscribe
More Newsletters
We use your sign-up to provide content in ways you’ve consented to and improve our understanding of you. This may include adverts from us and third parties based on our knowledge of you. More info
Paulo Bernardo had to wait his turn on MatchDay One. Heading to Dortmund, he’s doing everything to be in the front of the queue this time around.
Brendan Rodgers has made it clear that everyone is part of this power-packed Celtic unit. But, clearly, all players want the starting nod. Bernardo didn’t get first call against Slovan Bratislava with Reo Hatate chosen alongside Callum McGrgeor and Arne Engels. Rodgers’ decision was bang on and could not be debated. His team hammered five goals and his engine-room starters were outstanding.
SIMILAR ARTICLES TO THIS
Powered by
Celtic sweep St Johnstone aside as champions ooze six appeal before date with Dortmund – 3 talking points
Celtic sweep St Johnstone aside as champions ooze six appeal before date with Dortmund – 3 talking points
Brendan Rodgers blasts TV deal demands as Celtic boss asks broadcasters ‘help our players out’
Brendan Rodgers blasts TV deal demands as Celtic boss asks broadcasters ‘help our players out’
Backslapping Celtic board need self awareness as cute Brendan Rodgers comments show who’s really driving the process
Backslapping Celtic board need self awareness as cute Brendan Rodgers comments show who’s really driving the process
3 low risk Hearts next boss candidates named by the Jury as Rangers get Europa League endorsement
3 low risk Hearts next boss candidates named by the Jury as Rangers get Europa League endorsement
Brendan Rodgers turning point in second Celtic coming named by Callum McGregor after boss ‘angriest I’ve seen him’
Brendan Rodgers turning point in second Celtic coming named by Callum McGregor after boss ‘angriest I’ve seen him’
Brendan Rodgers keeps the Celtic receipts as he can’t resist clapback at style snipers after St Johnstone thrashing
Brendan Rodgers keeps the Celtic receipts as he can’t resist clapback at style snipers after St Johnstone thrashing
Current Celtic team vs Invincibles debated by Monday Jury as Rangers, Hearts and Hoops’ Euro chances rated
Current Celtic team vs Invincibles debated by Monday Jury as Rangers, Hearts and Hoops’ Euro chances rated
Liam Scales reveals Celtic pre match routine he will follow in Dortmund before ‘getting down to business’
Liam Scales reveals Celtic pre match routine he will follow in Dortmund before ‘getting down to business’
Celtic news bulletin as Borussia Dortmund told to strip captain of armband and loan flop still hasn’t kicked a ball
Celtic news bulletin as Borussia Dortmund told to strip captain of armband and loan flop still hasn’t kicked a ball
Liam Fox told Hearts job chances as Andrew McKinlay gives update on new manager search
Liam Fox told Hearts job chances as Andrew McKinlay gives update on new manager search
The Brendan Rodgers premonition that Celtic proved right as flying Hoops set unwanted record straight
The Brendan Rodgers premonition that Celtic proved right as flying Hoops set unwanted record straight
Scott Brown rung up Brendan Rodgers before saying no to St Johnstone as Celtic boss gave ‘recommendation’ over future
Scott Brown rung up Brendan Rodgers before saying no to St Johnstone as Celtic boss gave ‘recommendation’ over future
Lawrence Shankland tell Hearts boo boys what they’re wrong about as he admits slump has ‘taken over’ his life
Lawrence Shankland tell Hearts boo boys what they’re wrong about as he admits slump has ‘taken over’ his life
Gareth Ainsworth’s Hearts will be cold blooded as frontman insists he’s the man to get Tynecastle rocking
Gareth Ainsworth’s Hearts will be cold blooded as frontman insists he’s the man to get Tynecastle rocking
Palma ‘open’ to exit, Bernabei ‘anxiety’ pinpointed and £8.3m wonderkid masterplan revealed – Celtic news bulletin
Palma ‘open’ to exit, Bernabei ‘anxiety’ pinpointed and £8.3m wonderkid masterplan revealed – Celtic news bulletin
St Mirren victory ‘relief’ for Mark O’Hara as Diarmuid O’Carroll set for Newcastle United move
St Mirren victory ‘relief’ for Mark O’Hara as Diarmuid O’Carroll set for Newcastle United move
James Tavernier finally breaks silence on Rangers fan backlash as captain faces awkward Celtic question
James Tavernier finally breaks silence on Rangers fan backlash as captain faces awkward Celtic question
Rangers deliver Europa League statement as Malmo troll attempt backfires with curse FINALLY broken – 5 talking points
Rangers deliver Europa League statement as Malmo troll attempt backfires with curse FINALLY broken – 5 talking points
Jon Moss leaves SFA VAR manager role after less than TWO months as he declares ‘I wish I could have stayed’
Jon Moss leaves SFA VAR manager role after less than TWO months as he declares ‘I wish I could have stayed’
Extraordinary Celtic ripped up Champions League script and here is what I would say to the doom merchants – Chris Sutton
Extraordinary Celtic ripped up Champions League script and here is what I would say to the doom merchants – Chris Sutton
Celtic sweep St Johnstone aside as champions ooze six appeal before date with Dortmund – 3 talking points
Celtic sweep St Johnstone aside as champions ooze six appeal before date with Dortmund – 3 talking points
Brendan Rodgers blasts TV deal demands as Celtic boss asks broadcasters ‘help our players out’
Brendan Rodgers blasts TV deal demands as Celtic boss asks broadcasters ‘help our players out’
Backslapping Celtic board need self awareness as cute Brendan Rodgers comments show who’s really driving the process
Backslapping Celtic board need self awareness as cute Brendan Rodgers comments show who’s really driving the process
3 low risk Hearts next boss candidates named by the Jury as Rangers get Europa League endorsement
3 low risk Hearts next boss candidates named by the Jury as Rangers get Europa League endorsement
Brendan Rodgers turning point in second Celtic coming named by Callum McGregor after boss ‘angriest I’ve seen him’
Brendan Rodgers turning point in second Celtic coming named by Callum McGregor after boss ‘angriest I’ve seen him’
Brendan Rodgers keeps the Celtic receipts as he can’t resist clapback at style snipers after St Johnstone thrashing
Brendan Rodgers keeps the Celtic receipts as he can’t resist clapback at style snipers after St Johnstone thrashing
Current Celtic team vs Invincibles debated by Monday Jury as Rangers, Hearts and Hoops’ Euro chances rated
Current Celtic team vs Invincibles debated by Monday Jury as Rangers, Hearts and Hoops’ Euro chances rated
Liam Scales reveals Celtic pre match routine he will follow in Dortmund before ‘getting down to business’
Liam Scales reveals Celtic pre match routine he will follow in Dortmund before ‘getting down to business’
Celtic news bulletin as Borussia Dortmund told to strip captain of armband and loan flop still hasn’t kicked a ball
Celtic news bulletin as Borussia Dortmund told to strip captain of armband and loan flop still hasn’t kicked a ball
Liam Fox told Hearts job chances as Andrew McKinlay gives update on new manager search
Liam Fox told Hearts job chances as Andrew McKinlay gives update on new manager search
The Brendan Rodgers premonition that Celtic proved right as flying Hoops set unwanted record straight
The Brendan Rodgers premonition that Celtic proved right as flying Hoops set unwanted record straight
Scott Brown rung up Brendan Rodgers before saying no to St Johnstone as Celtic boss gave ‘recommendation’ over future
Scott Brown rung up Brendan Rodgers before saying no to St Johnstone as Celtic boss gave ‘recommendation’ over future
Lawrence Shankland tell Hearts boo boys what they’re wrong about as he admits slump has ‘taken over’ his life
Lawrence Shankland tell Hearts boo boys what they’re wrong about as he admits slump has ‘taken over’ his life
Gareth Ainsworth’s Hearts will be cold blooded as frontman insists he’s the man to get Tynecastle rocking
Gareth Ainsworth’s Hearts will be cold blooded as frontman insists he’s the man to get Tynecastle rocking
Palma ‘open’ to exit, Bernabei ‘anxiety’ pinpointed and £8.3m wonderkid masterplan revealed – Celtic news bulletin
Palma ‘open’ to exit, Bernabei ‘anxiety’ pinpointed and £8.3m wonderkid masterplan revealed – Celtic news bulletin
St Mirren victory ‘relief’ for Mark O’Hara as Diarmuid O’Carroll set for Newcastle United move
St Mirren victory ‘relief’ for Mark O’Hara as Diarmuid O’Carroll set for Newcastle United move
James Tavernier finally breaks silence on Rangers fan backlash as captain faces awkward Celtic question
James Tavernier finally breaks silence on Rangers fan backlash as captain faces awkward Celtic question
Rangers deliver Europa League statement as Malmo troll attempt backfires with curse FINALLY broken – 5 talking points
Rangers deliver Europa League statement as Malmo troll attempt backfires with curse FINALLY broken – 5 talking points
Jon Moss leaves SFA VAR manager role after less than TWO months as he declares ‘I wish I could have stayed’
Jon Moss leaves SFA VAR manager role after less than TWO months as he declares ‘I wish I could have stayed’
Extraordinary Celtic ripped up Champions League script and here is what I would say to the doom merchants – Chris Sutton
Extraordinary Celtic ripped up Champions League script and here is what I would say to the doom merchants – Chris Sutton
Celtic sweep St Johnstone aside as champions ooze six appeal before date with Dortmund – 3 talking points
Celtic sweep St Johnstone aside as champions ooze six appeal before date with Dortmund – 3 talking points
Brendan Rodgers blasts TV deal demands as Celtic boss asks broadcasters ‘help our players out’
Brendan Rodgers blasts TV deal demands as Celtic boss asks broadcasters ‘help our players out’
Backslapping Celtic board need self awareness as cute Brendan Rodgers comments show who’s really driving the process
Backslapping Celtic board need self awareness as cute Brendan Rodgers comments show who’s really driving the process
3 low risk Hearts next boss candidates named by the Jury as Rangers get Europa League endorsement
3 low risk Hearts next boss candidates named by the Jury as Rangers get Europa League endorsement
Brendan Rodgers turning point in second Celtic coming named by Callum McGregor after boss ‘angriest I’ve seen him’
Brendan Rodgers turning point in second Celtic coming named by Callum McGregor after boss ‘angriest I’ve seen him’
Brendan Rodgers keeps the Celtic receipts as he can’t resist clapback at style snipers after St Johnstone thrashing
Brendan Rodgers keeps the Celtic receipts as he can’t resist clapback at style snipers after St Johnstone thrashing
Current Celtic team vs Invincibles debated by Monday Jury as Rangers, Hearts and Hoops’ Euro chances rated
Current Celtic team vs Invincibles debated by Monday Jury as Rangers, Hearts and Hoops’ Euro chances rated
Liam Scales reveals Celtic pre match routine he will follow in Dortmund before ‘getting down to business’
Liam Scales reveals Celtic pre match routine he will follow in Dortmund before ‘getting down to business’
Celtic news bulletin as Borussia Dortmund told to strip captain of armband and loan flop still hasn’t kicked a ball
Celtic news bulletin as Borussia Dortmund told to strip captain of armband and loan flop still hasn’t kicked a ball
Liam Fox told Hearts job chances as Andrew McKinlay gives update on new manager search
Liam Fox told Hearts job chances as Andrew McKinlay gives update on new manager search
The Brendan Rodgers premonition that Celtic proved right as flying Hoops set unwanted record straight
The Brendan Rodgers premonition that Celtic proved right as flying Hoops set unwanted record straight
Scott Brown rung up Brendan Rodgers before saying no to St Johnstone as Celtic boss gave ‘recommendation’ over future
Scott Brown rung up Brendan Rodgers before saying no to St Johnstone as Celtic boss gave ‘recommendation’ over future
Lawrence Shankland tell Hearts boo boys what they’re wrong about as he admits slump has ‘taken over’ his life
Lawrence Shankland tell Hearts boo boys what they’re wrong about as he admits slump has ‘taken over’ his life
Gareth Ainsworth’s Hearts will be cold blooded as frontman insists he’s the man to get Tynecastle rocking
Gareth Ainsworth’s Hearts will be cold blooded as frontman insists he’s the man to get Tynecastle rocking
Palma ‘open’ to exit, Bernabei ‘anxiety’ pinpointed and £8.3m wonderkid masterplan revealed – Celtic news bulletin
Palma ‘open’ to exit, Bernabei ‘anxiety’ pinpointed and £8.3m wonderkid masterplan revealed – Celtic news bulletin
St Mirren victory ‘relief’ for Mark O’Hara as Diarmuid O’Carroll set for Newcastle United move
St Mirren victory ‘relief’ for Mark O’Hara as Diarmuid O’Carroll set for Newcastle United move
James Tavernier finally breaks silence on Rangers fan backlash as captain faces awkward Celtic question
James Tavernier finally breaks silence on Rangers fan backlash as captain faces awkward Celtic question
Rangers deliver Europa League statement as Malmo troll attempt backfires with curse FINALLY broken – 5 talking points
Rangers deliver Europa League statement as Malmo troll attempt backfires with curse FINALLY broken – 5 talking points
Jon Moss leaves SFA VAR manager role after less than TWO months as he declares ‘I wish I could have stayed’
Jon Moss leaves SFA VAR manager role after less than TWO months as he declares ‘I wish I could have stayed’
Extraordinary Celtic ripped up Champions League script and here is what I would say to the doom merchants – Chris Sutton
Extraordinary Celtic ripped up Champions League script and here is what I would say to the doom merchants – Chris Sutton
Bernardo played his part that night with a cameo role off the bench, but going out to Germany, he has seriously forwarded a compelling case to move up the chain. Of course, St Johnstone are not Borussia Dortmund, who will pose a far-stiffer examination. But Bernardo was scintillating against the Perth side. Chosen ahead of Hatate, every aspect of the game was on point.
READ MORE: Dortmund embroiled in civil war ahead of Celtic Champions League clash as Sahin and Sabitzer clash
READ MORE: Nicky Devlin talks night and day Aberdeen reaction from last Dundee visit as Jimmy Thelin matches Martin O’Neill record
Naturally, the 22-year-old caught attention with the stylish finish to cap his team’s simply breathtaking second goal, especially given he’d also been part of the astounding nine-man, 11-pass build-up. Bernardo was also right there to head a third if Kyogo hadn’t beaten him to Greg Taylor’s cross and his own in-perfect delivery for Daizen Maeda’s bullet-header fifth after a driving forward run was another piece of class.
He stamped his quality offensively, grafted relentlessly and then showed his versatility by slotting back to anchor in the closing stages with McGregor taken off. The skipper and Engels are surely nailed-on Dortmund starters and that leaves the choice between Bernardo and Hatate. It can’t be an easy one. The thought of Hatate, with his wizardly talents, not starting in a Champions League crunch if fit says everything about the squad power. This is exactly what Rodgers wanted, exactly why he’s building a unit with depth and genuine quality.
It can only be a tight decision. Hatate can make magic, yet some will argue that Bernardo takes more care of the ball in his own half, a crucial trait away from home against top Euro opposition.
Top Stories
1
Dortmund embroiled in civil war ahead of Celtic Champions League clash as Sahin and Sabitzer clash
2
Nicky Devlin talks night and day Aberdeen reaction from last Dundee visit as Jimmy Thelin matches Martin O’Neill record
3
Billy Gilmour Napoli ‘risk’ pays off as Antonio Conte gets exactly what he expected in Palermo rout
Celtic’s Kyogo Furuhashi (centre) celebrates scoring to make it 2-0 with Greg Taylor, Reo Hatate and Daizen Maeda during a UEFA Champions League against SK Slovan Bratislava
Although midfield looks like the tightest call, Rodgers had more choices to make. In attack, Kyogo is right on the mood with his lively performance and expert finishing in Perth. The Japanese’s speed and clinical edge got him his first and sharp movement coupled with a precise header after another sweeping team-move doubled his own tally.
Kyogo scores in big games. He did it against Rangers and Bratislava and looks the safest bet, yet Adam Idah’s ready and offers other strengths. Perhaps a better option to hold it up if Celtic need to get out, he’s also finding the net. Idah has four in three games, including one against Slovan, and his finish for goal six here capped an exquisite move and back-flick assist by Alex Valle.
Defensively, Rodgers’ hand may be forced. With Cameron Carter- Vickers toiling, Auston Trusty secured a valuable 90 minutes and looked powerful. The American felt his way into things against Falkirk the previous week and this was a huge step up in solidity. Trusty was strong and displayed pace to thwart Makenzie Kirk in the opening stages. He moved it well, even on his wrong side playing on the right of Liam Scales, was highly unfortunate to have a foul called against him when Maeda hit the net as he looked a threat in the opposing box and he also stepped out the backline to hit a dipping volley just wide. Valle was also given the second period in place of Taylor as the manager got more valuable minutes into the young left-back and his run and lay-off at the sumptuous sixth goal was jaw dropping.
Taylor’s calf will be assessed for Dortmund, but Alistair Johnston is ready and Kasper Schmeichel chalked up a club-record-equalling sixth-straight clean sheet to start the Premiership term. Right now, Celtic have players in every area who are on fire, none more so than Nicolas Kuhn. He’s openly targeting a place in Germany’s full national squad and as the perfect opportunity to show himself on home soil.
Kuhn was terrific again in Perth as he teased and tormented. His roles in goals, especially the third, were sublime and he’s giving Rodgers that demanded off-ball output.
Drey Wright and Celtic’s Daizen Maeda in (Image: SNS Group)
SIMILAR ARTICLES TO THIS
Powered by
Current Celtic team vs Invincibles debated by Monday Jury as Rangers, Hearts and Hoops’ Euro chances rated
Current Celtic team vs Invincibles debated by Monday Jury as Rangers, Hearts and Hoops’ Euro chances rated
Liam Scales reveals Celtic pre match routine he will follow in Dortmund before ‘getting down to business’
Liam Scales reveals Celtic pre match routine he will follow in Dortmund before ‘getting down to business’
Celtic news bulletin as Borussia Dortmund told to strip captain of armband and loan flop still hasn’t kicked a ball
Celtic news bulletin as Borussia Dortmund told to strip captain of armband and loan flop still hasn’t kicked a ball
Liam Fox told Hearts job chances as Andrew McKinlay gives update on new manager search
Liam Fox told Hearts job chances as Andrew McKinlay gives update on new manager search
The Brendan Rodgers premonition that Celtic proved right as flying Hoops set unwanted record straight
The Brendan Rodgers premonition that Celtic proved right as flying Hoops set unwanted record straight
Scott Brown rung up Brendan Rodgers before saying no to St Johnstone as Celtic boss gave ‘recommendation’ over future
Scott Brown rung up Bren
