St James’ Park erupted in anticipation, but the decision was swiftly reviewed by VAR. Following detailed replays, the spot kick was overturned, with officials concluding that Pope made contact with the ball before the collision.
The call has been the subject of heated debate among supporters and pundits, with many insisting that the goalkeeper’s follow-through still amounted to a foul. However, a clear verdict has now been delivered: under current laws, the decision to cancel the penalty was correct. VAR experts highlighted that once a defender makes a genuine touch on the ball, subsequent contact is not always deemed a foul unless it is reckless or excessive.
Newcastle manager Eddie Howe admitted the moment was pivotal but refrained from openly criticising the officials, while Arsenal boss Mikel Arteta expressed relief, insisting VAR should only intervene when there is a “clear and obvious error.” The controversy may rage on among fans, but the final judgment confirms that no mistake was made in disallowing the penalty.
Want me to also prepare a shorter version (about 80–100 words) for quick social media updates?
Be the first to comment